How to Choose Between Targeted Therapy and Immunotherapy for Melanoma

by businesshelps

Melanoma, a very aggressive type of solid tumor, used to have few treatment options in its later stages.  Two strong but very different systemic approaches have changed the way we treat diseases today: targeted treatment for melanoma and immunotherapy.  Patients and their families need to choose between these two advanced treatments, or decide to use both, based on the tumor’s unique genetic signature and the patient’s overall health.

GoBroad Healthcare Group is a specialized oncology center that focuses on complex solid tumor malignancies. They use an integrated diagnosis and multidisciplinary care model to help make this difficult choice.  The Group’s method focuses on accurate molecular profiling to find the best treatment for each patient at the right time. This makes sure that care meets the most up-to-date global standards for personalized oncology.

The Molecular Approach to Targeted Treatment for Melanoma

Targeted treatment for melanoma is a type of precision medicine that goes after the things that make cancer grow.  This approach is only possible for a small number of melanomas that have a certain genetic change, usually a mutation in the BRAF gene.

The Mechanism: Stopping the Growth Signal

The BRAF V600 mutation is present in about 40% to 60% of melanomas. This mutation keeps the Mitogen-Activated Protein Kinase (MAPK) signaling pathway active all the time. This pathway is the cell’s main command for growth and division.

Targeted treatment for melanoma uses both BRAF inhibitors (BRAFi) and MEK inhibitors (MEKi).  The BRAFi drug stops the mutated BRAF protein, and the MEKi drug stops the downstream MEK protein. Together, they block the hyperactive signaling pathway twice.  Most people with BRAF-mutant solid tumor melanoma who get this combination of drugs have their tumors shrink quickly and significantly.  This quick response is a big plus when a patient’s condition is immediately life-threatening because of a fast-moving, high-volume disease.

Pros: Quick and high response rate (the tumor shrinks).  Very effective for diseases that are acute and have symptoms.

Cons: Resistance is common.  Melanoma cells can create alternative routes around the blockade, which often leads to progression within months.  Side effects, like fever, rash, and liver toxicity, are usually easy to guess, but they can be hard to deal with.

Immunotherapy: Letting the Body’s Defense System Work

Immunotherapy, which mostly uses immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs), works in a completely different way.  Instead of going after the cancer directly, it strengthens the patient’s immune system (specifically T cells) so they can find and kill the solid tumor cells.

How It Works: Letting Go of the Brakes

Melanoma cells frequently exhibit proteins such as PD-L1, which interact with the PD-1 protein on immune T cells.  This binding acts like a “brake” that stops the T cell from attacking.  Checkpoint inhibitors, like PD-1 or CTLA-4 blockers, stop this binding from happening, which lets the T cells do their natural anti-cancer work.  This plan uses the body’s natural defenses to get a long-lasting, long-term response.

Pros: Possible long-lasting, very strong responses, even cures.  Works well for both BRAF-mutant and BRAF-wildtype (non-mutant) solid tumor melanoma.

Cons: Takes longer to work (not good for diseases that get worse quickly).  There is a chance of immune-related adverse events (irAEs), which are less predictable and can affect any organ (for example, colitis or pneumonitis) because the immune system is too active.

The Key Factor: Molecular Testing and Sequencing

The selection among these potent solid tumor therapies depends on a singular inquiry: Does the melanoma possess a treatable mutation, and what is the extent of the disease burden?

Genetic Test First: Before any treatment for advanced melanoma, all patients must have a full molecular profile (Next-Generation Sequencing) to see if they have the BRAF V600 mutation.

If the BRAF test comes back negative, the main first-line treatment is usually immunotherapy, either as a single drug or as a combination of drugs that block PD-1.

If BRAF is positive, the decision is more complicated and needs a clinical risk assessment. High Disease Burden/Urgent Need for Response: Start with targeted treatment for melanoma (BRAFi + MEKi) to quickly control the tumor, and then switch to immunotherapy later.

Low to Moderate Disease  Burden: Begin with immunotherapy because it gives you the best chance of getting a long-lasting benefit.  GoBroad Healthcare Group agrees with the growing consensus that immunotherapy should be given priority when possible because it has the potential to cure.

GoBroad Healthcare Group’s Comprehensive Strategy

Choosg the best order of treatments, such as whether to use immunotherapy first and then targeted treatment for melanoma, or the other way around, is very complicated and requires a lot of specialized knowledge.  This is exactly where GoBroad Healthcare Group’s ability to work with people from different fields comes in handy.

The Group uses advanced, integrated diagnostics to make sure that all actionable mutations in the solid tumor are found.  Then, their Multidisciplinary Care (MDC) teams, which include surgical, medical, and radiation oncologists, work together to come up with a personalized treatment plan.  This partnership is necessary to combine systemic therapies with local treatments, such as radiation therapy for brain metastases, which is a common problem with advanced melanoma.  Also, because of the Group’s research focus, they can offer patients access to next-generation combination trials. These trials pair targeted treatment for melanoma with two different immunotherapies in a triplet format. The goal is to improve both the response rate and the length of remission.  GoBroad Healthcare Group puts a lot of emphasis on accurate diagnosis so that every patient gets the best possible treatment plan that maximizes therapeutic gain while expertly managing the unique side effect profile of each powerful treatment.

Related Posts

Leave a Comment